Page 1 of 29

Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2022 5:14 pm
by jkim
Ready to spin up a new project. Taking a break from my usual Luftwaffe/Axis subjects, I wanted to revisit another Allied aircraft and try an Olive Drab/Neutral Grey scheme. I've decided to on this one...

Image
Image
Image

This is a P-47D-11-RE Razorback Thunderbolt manufactured at the Republic factory. It was piloted by Lt. Frank Oiler of the 78th FG of the 84th FS based at Duxford, England, 1944.

I'll be using the 1/32 Trumpeter kit for this build. I've reviewed multiple online builds of this kit. I have to admit that Trumpeter is not my favorite model company but from what I've read on line, the Jug is one of their better efforts. I expect some fit issues but hopefully we can overcome those and present a decent result.
Image

An interesting aspect of this kit is the inclusion of a clear, 1-piece engine cowling. To Trumpeter's credit, the cowling is VERY clear to facilitate a view of the engine details but needless to say, I'll be painting this one!
Image

The traditional clear parts: windscreen and sliding canopy look ok.
Image
Image

The front face of the instrument panel is presented as a clear part. The intention is to view the instrument details, supplied as a sheet of printed acetate, through the clear plastic. If so, why in the world would you mold instrument details onto the clear part? Nope, doesn't make sense but I'll be using an Eduard instrument panel and I can just leapfrog this silliness altogether.
Image

It's a shame because the acetate instrument panel is rather well-detailed. Builders wishing to utilize the kit parts could attempt to salvage this situation by drilling the gauge openings from the clear instrument panel. Also included in the kit are some rudimentary photoetch parts including very simplified seat harnesses, which I'll be replacing with the HGW product.
Image

Jumping to the main plastic parts, we find a very squat looking fuselage on Sprue A. Big and beefy is how I would describe this aircraft.
Image

The entire exterior surface of the model is covered in rivets, represented by small holes. Some like this, some hate it. I consider myself neutral. I happen to like the look of rivets presented as small holes, but I prefer the smaller holes produced by using a rotary riveting wheel. For this build, I am trading in a bit of refinement for a lot less work and I'm ok with that.
Image
Image
Image

The wings make up the biggest sprue in the box.
Image

Some panels are left open if the modeler wishes to show the machine gun stations and ammo feeds. I'll be closing this model up so I'm hoping that these panels have a decent fit.
Image
Image

Four prop and two engine cowling options are provided but the Trumpeter instructions offer no guidance whatsoever on the differences or applicability of these options.
Image
Image

Which prop does this look like?
Image

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2022 7:45 pm
by keavdog
Looking forward to this. I want to see what you do with the OD over grey.

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2022 7:58 pm
by Stikpusher
Oh yeah! The Jug is a favorite of mine! A big brute of a radial engined fighter, like the F6F and F4U.

The prop on Eileen in the photo looks like the cuffed symmetrical paddle blade prop - the type on the lower left corner of the sprue. I’d have to check my Detail & Scale book to find the name of exact type in the photo. Nice that the kit includes all the different types used on the P-47. The original narrow prop, the two types of symmetrical paddle blades, and the asymmetrical paddle blade types. I remember reading in Robert Johnson’s autobiography how the paddle blade props really allowed the P-47 to harness the horsepower of the R-2800 engine and climb.

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2022 8:45 pm
by Medicman71
Oh this is gonna be another good one! The Jug is definitely a favorite of mine as well.

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2022 9:23 pm
by BlackSheep214
Oh yeah, so looking forward to following this one. :lashed:

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 6:12 am
by mustang1989
I feel exactly the same way you do about Trumpeter. So over engineered a lot of their kits are that I won't even bother with them. If this kit is a departure from that norm, then they may be on the right track.

Looking forward to this John.

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 11:39 am
by Stuart
:popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn:

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 1:03 pm
by jkim
Thanks guys! Appreciate the comments. I'm actually quite excited to start this one.
Stikpusher wrote: Thu Nov 17, 2022 7:58 pm Oh yeah! The Jug is a favorite of mine! A big brute of a radial engined fighter, like the F6F and F4U.

The prop on Eileen in the photo looks like the cuffed symmetrical paddle blade prop - the type on the lower left corner of the sprue. I’d have to check my Detail & Scale book to find the name of exact type in the photo. Nice that the kit includes all the different types used on the P-47. The original narrow prop, the two types of symmetrical paddle blades, and the asymmetrical paddle blade types. I remember reading in Robert Johnson’s autobiography how the paddle blade props really allowed the P-47 to harness the horsepower of the R-2800 engine and climb.
I agree about the prop in the lower left being the best match. Hey Carlos... Is the Detail & Scale book worth getting as a reference for this build? I don't have much besides scans of the Squadron Walkaround and a couple of Kagero publications. Does the D&S book have any cockpit shots?

I've already shown the big important sprues so let's wrap up the sprue tour with the rest of the smaller frets. Another interesting aspect of this kit is Trumpeter's inclusion of the supercharger ducting, which becomes completely invisible after construction.
Image

There are two identical sprues of ordinance, with some choices in drop tanks, bombs and even some small rockets.
Image

All of the control surfaces are separately molded, which allows them to posed dynamically, if desired.
Image
Image

Image
Image
Image

Trumpeter gives the Pratt & Whitney R2800 Double Wasp engine a lot of love and three separate sprues are dedicated just to the powerplant. The back of the engine is given as much attention as the front but for my build, cowling on and painted, I'll be concentrating on the view from the front.
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image

Two sprues for the eight Browning machine guns. The blast tube ends are molded with hollowed out ends, which is a nice touch. The instructions indicate that the machine guns are to be assembled and installed prior to the wing halves coming together. Not ideal since this would interfere with the seam work and painting. The bays on this aircraft will be closed so I'll be looking for ways to allow the insertion of the blast tubes after wing construction.
Image
Image

The final sprue includes all of the cockpit parts. There is no AM resin available for the Trumpeter Razorback that I am aware of. I have the Eduard PE interior set coming to help spiffy up the interior.
Image
Image
Image

The landing gear legs look pretty basic and appear to be fully compressed.
Image
Image

That's it for the kit parts.

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 1:39 pm
by Stikpusher
John, I’d say yes, the Detail & Scale book is worth getting. Especially if you’re planning to build more than one of the type. P-47s do tend to capture the imagination as you research them and will draw you deeper down that path. There are good cockpit photos in the book, particularly some un restored types, so bonus points there for time capsule value.

That Trumpeter kit sure is a far cry from the old Revell 1/32 Jug kits. I’m looking forward to watching you work your talents on this project! :hmm:

Re: Trumpeter P-47D Razorback "Eileen"

Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2022 2:45 pm
by jkim
Thanks Carlos! I was eyeing that book and your recommendation pushed it over the top. I found it on ebay for less than $20 shipped so I have another incoming goody for this build!